Before embarkation: compare arrival-day risk and an overnight
Compare same-day arrival with a pre-cruise overnight by tracing the whole route to boarding.

A flight that lands on embarkation day can appear to fit the cruise perfectly. The important comparison is whether the whole arrival chain fits the boarding requirements, and what you would do if it does not.
A pre-cruise overnight buys time before the sailing. It adds cost and does not remove every disruption risk. Compare both versions honestly before choosing.
Start with boarding, not departure
Find the current requirements for your cruise, port and booking. The ship’s published sailing time is not a promise that guests can arrive at the terminal just beforehand.
Royal Caribbean’s port-arrival FAQ directs guests to the selected arrival slot and highlights check-in, boarding and port-operating requirements. Read the current instructions for your sailing rather than borrowing a single cutoff from someone else’s itinerary. Official arrival guidance.
Then work backwards through the transfer, leaving the airport, any entry formalities and baggage collection. An airport arrival time is only one point in that sequence.
Compare the overnight as a complete addition
Use fictional figures to make the method visible. Suppose arriving the day before adds a $180 room, $35 in additional transport and $40 of meals you would not otherwise buy. That is $255 of incremental cost.
Do not add meals already in both versions or assume the hotel includes the port transfer. Use the actual arrangements and cancellation terms you could book.
What does the extra night change? Perhaps you can reach the port from a nearby base on sailing day rather than directly from a flight. That may be valuable to you even though it is not a guarantee against a cancelled flight the previous day.

Name the same-day fallback
If your flight is delayed, who do you contact and what options are actually available? Do not assume you may join at the next port, that the ship will wait or that another airline seat will be affordable.
A cruise-line air product may have specific assistance terms. Read that product’s conditions rather than interpreting “booked together” as unlimited protection. Insurance is also a separate contract; check the risks and limits you intend to rely on.
If the fallback is something you could not realistically carry out, keep that limitation visible in the decision.
Compare the whole trip before paying
A lower airfare can be a poor saving if it leaves an arrival plan you are uncomfortable relying on. Equally, an elaborate overnight arrangement is not automatically useful if its own transport and access remain uncertain.
The cruise quote-comparison guide helps compare complete prices. Booking direct or through an agent considers who handles the booking and changes.
Choose the arrival version whose cost, dependencies and limitations you understand. Do not let a neat-looking timetable make the decision for you.
For a related next step, read a flight after disembarkation: what must happen first?.